Usually whenever dates are provided, they are considering having day of times you to definitely do not meets with this date whilst from inside the genuine history. One example happens in Harry Potter therefore the Prisoner out-of Azkaban whenever Sybill Trelawney means 16 October because the Tuesday, even though sixteen October 1993 was a tuesday.
It is possible, although not unlikely, you to definitely Fudge might be writing about an even more distant ancestor, as Thatcher got work environment just before Fudge purportedly turned Minister for Wonders
There are even contradictions when you look at the instructions in this region. Instance, inside the Harry Potter and Goblet regarding Fire, both step one September and you can 2 Sep are supplied once the Mondays and you may, when you look at the Harry Potter and Prisoner of Azkaban, Buckbeak’s demo is determined to your 20 April, however, careful parsing of text demonstrates that this may possess occurred no later than simply February.
Along with, for the Harry Potter and the Goblet out of Fire they claim that Champions had been chosen toward Monday 30 Oct, but 30 Oct is a tuesday during the 1994. But not, it was after stated that twenty-two November is actually a saturday, which it was in 1994.
From inside the chapter 7 away from Quidditch From Years, they claim that very first Quidditch Globe Mug happened during the 1473. When your championship are kept most of the couple of years, it problems to the report within the Cup off Fire the 1994 World Glass try the 422nd. In the event that Quidditch Through the Ages is great, this new 422nd Quidditch Community Cup perform actually fall in the season 3161, but if Cup regarding Fire is useful, the first Globe Mug is kept inside the 306.
Historical problems
While the show, according to the timeline produced by the new Chamber off Secrets source, is decided on the 1990s, new series will appears like it is set in the late 1990s to help you mid-2000s, roughly concurrent into publication of your own books. In Harry Potter additionally the 50 % of-Blood Prince, Cornelius Fudge uses a masculine pronoun to mention toward “predecessor” of Primary Minister of one’s United kingdom. With respect to the over timeline, this would occur in the summer months regarding 1996, when the Finest Minister is John Major, whose instantaneous predecessor try a female (‘s earliest meeting with Fudge, the ebook mentions the fresh election, however, Biggest wasn’t 1st chose and simply took more immediately following Thatcher resigned.
(In the event it’s possible to thought a scenario where Fudge is actually delegated from the Minister getting Secret to fulfill to your Primary Minister while he, Fudge, was a student in a smaller work environment.) On top of that, the fresh new identity and you can reputation for the top Minister portrayed generally seems to far more closely match regarding Tony Blair than regarding John Major. A post from the Each day Post notes that Rowling is actually intimate on the next-Chancellor of your Exchequer Gordon Brown (commonly seen as a competition so you can Blair’s frontrunners of one’s Labour Team, which been successful your and you can became Finest Minister), and that she could have been wanting to tell you https://www.datingmentor.org/escort/evansville/ Blair’s worst front. If for example the guides were devote sync having book big date of Philosopher’s Brick, after that that it feel manage take place in 2002 (shortly after Blair turned Perfect Minister).
An identical situation concerns Nicolas Flamel, who had been stated to be 665 during the fresh new very first guide, but Nicolas Flamel is a bona fide historical profile and wouldn’t reach that decades until 1996, within the date the original guide try blogged. The latest rebuttal because of it is the fact that day the fresh “real” Nicolas Flamel was given birth to will not correspond with the brand new Nicolas Flamel off Harry Potter.
Another situation is present off Rubeus Hagrid’s period since Hogwarts’s gamekeeper. It’s meant regarding the series one Hagrid got you to definitely reputation in this many years out-of his expulsion away from school inside the 1942. In you to scene out of Harry Potter while the Cup off Flame, Molly Weasley reminisces in the Ogg, Hagrid’s preekeeper appear to convergence which have Molly’s many years in school, it looks unrealistic that she remembers a past gamekeeper. However, it is possible one to Hagrid didn’t end up being a beneficial gamekeeper immediately after being expelled, but rather come because the Ogg’s secretary. This is certainly probable due to the fact whenever Harry thinks he often getting expelled having traveling for the broomstick without permission in his first year, the guy wonders in the event that he would be allowed to stick to just like the Hagrid’s secretary.